Spotted Owl May Go Extinct Anyway
Scientists believe barred owls have taken over the spotted owl territory and the survivors may have fled. "Natural systems are pretty unpredictable," said Eric Forsman, U.S, Forest Service biologist. "When you set about trying to manage a particular species there are lots of things that can happen that are unplanned."
Author Ron Arnold said the concession vindicates the loggers who all along proclaimed their innocence. "You can't turn nature into a museum even though environmentalists try."
Arnold also noted that "more than 22,000 logging jobs vanished [because of the owl fiasco]." The jobs and the towns destroyed are likely gone forever, but "environmentalists refuse to give an inch."
No matter, say the environmentalists, if it's too late for the spotted owl then they will demand the forests remain closed to protect something else. They claim the timber industry won't bother to fight this time (because most are out of business). It is more economically feasible to import lumber from foreign countries with cheap labor and fewer ridiculous environmental regulations - the types of protections that activists promised would save the spotted owl.
Spotted Owls Endangered by Logging or Nature?
Protective efforts for the owls led to timber industry wars in the 1980s and the walling off of millions of acres of forest to loggers — but the spotted owl is being replaced by a heartier feathered foe — the barred owl.
"Natural systems are pretty unpredictable,” Eric Forsman, a U.S. forest service biologist, said. “When you set about trying to manage a particular species there are lots of things that can happen that are unplanned."
Author Ron Arnold said this discovery vindicates the loggers who claimed all along the owls' precarious position wasn’t their problem. “What's happening is a natural process,” he said. "You can't turn nature into a museum even though environmentalists try. But I think they should be very apologetic and do some reparations — put the loggers back.
“Studies show more than 22,000 logging jobs vanished because of the battle to save the spotted owl, devastating small mill towns throughout the Northwest. They're jobs that despite this new research are likely gone forever as environmental groups refuse to give an inch."
The Audubon Society wants all old-growth logging banned and more tree-cutting restrictions on private land, if too late for the spotted owl then for the rest of the forest’s animals. Critics say it’s time for better balance between man and nature.
"If we give up now and we take the argument that they're declining, let's give up, let's just log it all anyway,” said Alex Morgan of the Audubon Society. “I think it's definitely a cop out but it's also inexcusable."
But industry experts say a second timber war is unlikely because wood is increasingly being imported from countries with cheap labor and less environmental protections — the types of protections that activists promised would save the spotted owl.
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, any copyrighted work in this message is distributed under fair use without profit or payment for non-profit research and educational purposes only. [Ref. http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml]