Public use
of Index wilderness debated


By Jim Haley
Herald Writer
from http://www.heraldnet.com/Stories/01/9/7/14337448.cfm#top
MONROE, WA - 9/7/01 -- Some were heartened by the prospect of
locking away more than 100,000 acres of mountain area near the
town of Index for recreation today and the enjoyment of future
generations.
Others are upset that more public land might be taken away
from uses they enjoy, such as riding snowmobiles and all-terrain
vehicles.
Many also flowed into the high school here Thursday night to
ask specific questions at a workshop hosted by two members of
the state's congressional delegation on the proposed
establishment of a new wilderness area north and east of Index.
Would float planes be allowed to drop off fishers and campers
at Lake Isabel?
Probably not, said Barbara Busse, the ranger for the U.S.
Forest Service's Skykomish Ranger District, which would manage
the proposed wilderness.
What about car camping at favorite sites off a road near
Silver Creek, someone asked? That would be eliminated, too,
Busse said, if the area were included in a wilderness.
The 110,000 acres under consideration is situated in chunks,
mostly in roadless areas draining the north and south forks of
the Skykomish River, all areas are north of U.S. 2. Some of it
borders Henry M. Jackson Wilderness. Most of the proposed area
is in Snohomish County, with a little flowing over into
northeast King County.
The exact proposed boundaries have not been fixed, but the
area is likely to include hundreds of mountain peaks, high
lakes, creeks and woodlands, including old-growth forests.
The big difference between this proposal and others in the
past is the inclusion of lowland forests, some with salmon
spawning creeks.
The workshop was hosted by Sen. Patty Murray and Rep. Rick
Larsen, who could propose federal legislation establishing the
"Wild Skykomish" wilderness as early as this fall, a
spokeswoman for Murray said.
Establishing wilderness would mean prohibition of most
mechanized vehicles, including snowmobiles, cars and mountain
bikes.
However, folks still would be able to hike, fish, hunt and
paddle canoes.
One question was fielded by Doug Scott, the policy director
for the Pew Wilderness Center, a Washington, D.C.-based
organization that aims to increase public understanding and
awareness of the nation's 644 wilderness areas.
Somebody wanted to know if wheelchairs would be allowed. In a
word, the answer is "yes," said Scott. Scott said some
wheelchairs might not be appropriate on rough trails, however.
Scott likes the fact that some lower elevation terrain is
included, not just rocks and mountain tops as in some wilderness
areas. We need to preserve "a diversity of all the
ecosystems that we enjoy around here, including salmon
habitat," Scott said.
Terry Jongejan of Snohomish is equally happy that the
wilderness has been proposed. She came to the workshop to
encourage lawmakers to continue.
An Everett teacher, Jongejan said she "works with
children and they need a future. The more we save of the
forests, especially old-growth forests, the better future
they'll have."
Others disagreed with her. Scott Atkinson of Monroe came to
protest the proposed wilderness.
"What I see happening here is cutting out a lot of user
groups, including senior citizens" who may not be able to
hike into the high country, said Atkinson, an avid outdoorsman.
Steve Purbaugh of Startup wondered if the government and
environmental groups were just taking another step to "lock
us out of all the land."
Purbaugh said he's been enjoying the woods for 47 years.
"Now people are going to come in and tell me I can't enjoy
(the land) the way I want to enjoy it." |